Thursday, December 2, 2010

Blame Canada

In today's Chumash the verse (42:28) speaks of the tribe's misfortunes, and they say, "What is this that G-d has done to us?" As far as I can tell, this is the first time in the Torah that people actively invoke Hashgocha Pratis in a negative manner. Before this, who ever blamed G-d when something went wrong? In fact, how many narratives went wrong in the first place? Sure, there are stories of G-d punishing people, but does anyone in those stories actively say, "Hey, this is G-d's fault, why is he doing this to me?" If I'm wrong, tell me.

21 comments:

Yossi said...

do you think you would have similar ruminations if you would learn your chitas at a normal hour in the day?

e said...

...And thus began the time-honored tradition of blaming god for everything.

e said...

Yossi: Is 10:50 such an ungodly hour for chitas?

Yossi said...

sometimes.

bonne said...

Yeah I would just stick to blaming Canada, keeps the wrath at bay.

e said...

Until one day the god of canada will smite you with a blizzard. or a glacier. or with molten polar ice caps.

e said...

or with products labelled exclusively in french!!

bonne said...

Heaven forfend, pointy sheos are hard enough to bear.

Just like a guy said...

Yossi: such as?

e: Hey, he does have wide shoulders.

Sara: what do you have against Canada?

e said...

pointy shoes are French, but are they Canadian?

bonne said...

Pointy shoes originate in France but like many religions, the Canadian one made it a part of it's own special tradition.

TRS, you and your wife were supposed to be at the big menorah lighting but I didn't see you two, nu nu?

Just like a guy said...

We were there, where were you? Did you perhaps go to the one in Brooklyn and not Manhattan?

bonne said...

Oh, yeah I went to the Brooklyn one.

C said...

Hey, don't hate on Canada.

Just like a guy said...

Sara: I figured.

C: Astute readers will notice that in this post I compared Canada to G-d.

C said...

I was referring to the comments...

But thanks :)

e said...

why do you go to public menorah lightings?

Just like a guy said...

It's a family-friendly (and free) activity.

e said...

...as is sitting on the couch in your warm house. Are these events fun? inspiring? anything other than (boredom + free donuts)?

Just like a guy said...

Yes, they're very inspiring. And there weren't any free doughnuts. Or indeed any doughnuts.

Anonymous said...

http://bdld.info/2010/12/07/the-spirit-he-breathed-in-man-is-free-the-theodicy-of-maimonides-and-kipling/